There's a Nail That Keeps Popping Out of My Wood Floor — Why?

You know the feeling. You're walking across your hardwood floor in socks, and suddenly there's a sharp little point digging into your foot — usually somewhere you weren't expecting it.

This May Also Interest You: How to Repair and Prevent Sun Fading on Your Hardwood Floors

A popped nail is one of the more common hardwood floor annoyances out there, and while it's rarely a sign of anything serious, it's also not the kind of thing that fixes itself. Here's what's going on and how to deal with it the right way.

Why Nails Sometimes Pop Out of Hardwood Floors

Hardwood flooring is nailed down — typically with flooring cleats or ring-shank nails driven through the tongue of each board into the subfloor below. Over time, a few things conspire to work those nails loose.

The biggest one is seasonal expansion and contraction. Wood absorbs and releases moisture depending on the humidity in your home throughout the year. In summer, boards soak up some of that moisture and expand slightly. In winter, when the heat is running and the air dries out, they shrink back down. Year after year, that constant swelling and shrinking can gradually loosen the grip the wood has on the nails — especially in homes where humidity swings quite a bit between seasons.

Subfloor movement plays a role too. If the subfloor isn't perfectly stable — maybe there's some deflection between joists, or the framing lumber has shrunk a bit over the years — the floor flexes slightly every time you walk on it. Each flex puts a little stress on the nails. Multiply that by years of foot traffic and eventually a nail head starts working its way up and out.

And sometimes it's just an installation issue. A nail that wasn't driven all the way in originally, or went in at a slight angle, is more likely to back itself out over time.

Is This the Same Thing as a Squeaky Floor?

Often, yes. A squeak happens when a loose board rubs against a nail or the subfloor as it flexes under your weight — and a popped nail is sometimes just the more visible result of that same loosening. If you've got both a squeak and a popped nail in the same spot, fixing the nail may take care of both at once.

Can You Just Pull the Nail Out?

Don't. It might seem like the obvious fix, but pulling the nail out leaves that spot of the board completely unsecured. It'll keep flexing. The empty hole can collect debris and moisture, and you've actually made the spot less stable than it was before. The right move is to deal with the nail in place — either re-set it or swap it for something with a better grip — not yank it and call it done.

How to Fix a Nail That Won't Stop Popping Out of Hardwood Flooring

Things You'll Need

• Nail set

• Hammer

• Power drill with a countersink bit

• Some wood screws (1 ¼ to 1 ½ inches works for standard ¾-inch hardwood)

• Wood putty that matches your floor's finish

• Fine-grit sandpaper

• Vacuum

Step-by-Step Instructions

Step 1: Take Stock

Before you fix anything, walk the area and see how widespread the problem actually is. Are there other spots that feel soft, squeaky or where you can see other nails starting to lift? If it's just the one nail, this is a quick job. But if a whole section of floor feels bouncy or loose, that's pointing at something going on with the subfloor — and that's a bigger conversation than just this one nail.

Step 2: Try Setting the Nail First

If the nail has only popped up a little and the wood around it still looks fine, start simple. Place your nail set on the head of the nail and tap it gently with the hammer until it sinks back down just below the surface — not so far that you tear up the wood around it. For a minor pop, this alone might solve the problem.

Step 3: Switch to a Screw for Anything More Serious

If the nail has come up significantly, or if this spot keeps acting up no matter what you do, a wood screw is going to hold a lot better than the original nail ever will. Pull the popped nail out with pliers — go slow so you don't split the wood around it. Drill a pilot hole slightly off from where the old nail was; going back into the exact same hole won't give the screw anything new to bite into. Then drive a wood screw through the board and into the subfloor or joist beneath it, using your countersink bit to sink the head just below the surface.

Step 4: Fill and Sand

Fill the hole with wood putty that matches your floor's color. Pile it on slightly — it shrinks a bit as it dries — and let it cure according to the package instructions. Once it's dry, sand it down flush with fine-grit sandpaper, vacuum up the dust and you're done.

When It's More Than Just a Nail

If you're seeing this happen in multiple spots across a room, or the whole area feels bouncy when you walk on it, the problem probably isn't the nails — it's whatever is going on underneath them. It's worth bringing in a flooring pro to take a look at the subfloor and joists if this is the case. Fixing the nails won't do much good if there's a bigger issue underneath causing them all to pop in the first place.